Peoples Geography — Reclaiming space

Creating people's geographies

Israeli Apartheid Comes to New Jersey

A very good piece by Saifedean Ammous in the Columbia Daily Spectator (rep. at Alternet), worth posting here in its entirety.

Israeli Apartheid Comes to New Jersey
By Saifedean Ammous | 5 March, 2007

It was a cold Sunday morning in Teaneck, N.J. Some two-hundred-odd Jewish-Americans were entering the Orthodox synagogue Congregation B’nai Yeshurun where they were to hear a sales pitch by the Amana Settlement Movement aimed at convincing them to buy homes in illegal Israeli settlements. America, the land that gave the world the separation of church and state, is hosting an auction where only members of one religious group can buy property.

And here I am, a Palestinian who grew up hundreds of meters away from some of these very settlements. I cannot buy any of these houses and am not admitted into the auction room. Literally and figuratively left out in the cold, I light a cigarette and get over it immediately; being denied entry is not an entirely novel experience for a Palestinian.

A group of around 50 pro-peace activists gather outside to protest the auction. Rabbi Steven Pruzansky comes out to speak to journalists; he doesn’t seem to understand the controversy. “Everyone can buy land anywhere. I was in the Bahamas and they were selling land; in Florida they sell land to anyone, why can’t we buy land in Israel?” When a journalist mentions to him that these are colonies for Jews only, he says that he prays hard for peace, and looks forward to the day when Jews and Arabs can live together, but for now this is hard because of the “security situation.” It doesn’t occur to him that this “security situation” may itself be the result of these exclusive colonies being built on stolen Palestinian land.

I ask a middle-aged man leaving the presentation what he thought of it. He tells me he will definitely move to Israel one day. I ask him if he knows anything about the legal status of these settlements; he tells me it is “unclaimed land.” I mention to him a recent report by Israeli group Peace Now which finds that 40 percent of settlements are built on confiscated private Palestinian land (as opposed to the other 60 percent that are built on illegally occupied land.) “Peace Now and B’Tselem are the two most anti-Semitic organizations in the world,” he replies, “Can they prove it?”

I tell him that this is based on documents from Israel’s “Civil Administration” and that the Israeli government never denied these reports, but he’s having none of it. I ask him if he thought about asking Amana about the legality of the land, but he answers with a stern “No, I don’t want to ask them. I don’t need to know.”

One of my most vivid memories of growing up under Israeli apartheid came in the summer of 1993, when our house in Ramallah would receive water only three days a week. I remember driving one day near the colony of Shilo (back in the good old days when we could still drive between Palestinian cities) and witnessing the water sprinklers bursting at full blast outside the settlement to water the surrounding hills, ensuring the view for the colonialists was a little greener. Someone today will buy a house in Shilo, and in a few years, on a hot summer day, she will wake up to this beautiful green view, while I would wake up praying there would be enough water to shower.

Settlements receive around 10 times the amount of water per capita that Palestinian cities and villages receive. While we had to resort to buying plastic dishes to cut down on dish-washing, they would spend their days in swimming pools enjoying the lush green views afforded to them by their sprinklers.

And today, this colonialism is taken to absurd lengths. Having helped turn the West Bank into the world’s biggest constellation of ghettoes surrounded by walls and racially-exclusive colonies and roads, Amana was still not satisfied. Nor were they satisfied with the economic and political support that the American government provides to the Israeli government’s abuses of human rights and international law. They had to squeeze money from the people of New Jersey to build more exclusive illegal colonies, dispossess more Palestinians, and take more water from my family. All part of “Keeping the Zionist Dream Alive,” as the Amana brochure put it.

Watching the quintessentially American family of a dad, mom, and three kids emerge enthusiastically from their blue Ford SUV toward the auction made me think of all the families I knew whose lands were taken by Israel; often forcefully displaced and separated, these families can not even buy these lands back if they wanted to. In “The Only Democracy in the Middle East,” real estate is run by imaginary ghosts from 3,000 year-old books that displace families from their only homes to auction them as second and third homes to Americans.

I wonder what drives this beautiful family to wake up on a Sunday morning and go find out about joining a colonial project instead of going to the mall; contributing to its success with their money by not knowing and not wanting to know about the reality of what they are getting into. It sounds too banal to be true, but a consumerism that willfully and consciously chooses to be blind to the consequences of its purchases is helping prop up the world’s only remaining colonial apartheid system.

The night before coming here, this family doubtlessly weighed the option of joining this project against skiing, shopping, or visiting relatives. Unfortunately for my future bathing prospects, they have decided to join in Amana’s quest to “Keep the Zionist Dream Alive.”

Saifedean Ammous is a PhD student in Sustainable Development at Columbia University in New York.

© 2007 Independent Media Institute. All rights reserved.
View this story online at:

3 comments on “Israeli Apartheid Comes to New Jersey

  1. Curtis
    13 March, 2007

    Very interesting story. I had no idea that this kind of thing went on, as far as Zionist recruitment drives or whatever one might call them.

  2. Lee
    27 April, 2007

    Not everyone realize what expansion of settlements means. It means that Jewish goverment can take land and build homes for Jewish people only. The Palestinians have lived on this land for thousand of years and have history in the homes in which they live. In a stroke of a pen, bulldozers and tanks arrive and remove the palestinians from their homes. THIS IS THE BOTTOM LINE BEHIND THE MDDLE EAST CONFLICT.

    It is the practice and policies of Israel for which it must be destroyed. Those policies are unfair and unjust.

    Because Israel was granted Statehood in the 1940’s, it is a recognized nation. A recognized nation can legally bear arms. This means that they can legally have an army with tanks, jet, helicopters and troops. They protray this status in the name of security, but use it for expansion of settlements.

    The Palestinians do not have the same status, do not have any security, do not have a recognized goverment and do not have any way to defend their homes. Everything that the Palestinians do for themselves for security and protection is illegal.

    This same conflict occurred in the 1100s and the Jews lost. They were given free passage to leave and they settled in Germany. After Hitler, the U.N. moved the Jewish people back to Israel and gave them statehood. That creation was the soley pushed by the United States, a country at the time that was in support of Jim Crow Laws and 400 years of slavery.

    The creation of Israel was done by racist in this country and still supported by lingerage of racist today.


  3. Lee
    27 April, 2007

    Oh, I am an African-American or Black, whichever. I haven’t any identity or ties from which I came. At least the Palestinians know their history and they are fighting to the death for theirs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Timely Reminders

"Those who crusade, not for God in themselves, but against the devil in others, never succeed in making the world better, but leave it either as it was, or sometimes perceptibly worse than what it was, before the crusade began. By thinking primarily of evil we tend, however excellent our intentions, to create occasions for evil to manifest itself."
-- Aldous Huxley

"The only war that matters is the war against the imagination. All others are subsumed by it."
-- Diane DiPrima, "Rant", from Pieces of a Song.

"It is difficult
to get the news from poems
yet men die miserably every day
for lack
of what is found there"
-- William Carlos Williams, "Asphodel, That Greeny Flower"