Peoples Geography — Reclaiming space

Creating people's geographies

Al Manar: The underground voice of Hezbollah

‘The underground voice of Hezbollah that Israel is still unable to silence’

| Times Online | Aug 5 2006

EVERY night of this 25-day-old conflict, Israeli warplanes have tried to destroy Hezbollah’s television station, al-Manar. Every night they have failed.

Somehow the satellite network continues to pump out its potent mix of news and propaganda from makeshift studios, its continued survival a deepening embarrassment to Israel’s much-vaunted military, and a growing inspiration to Hezbollah sympathisers.



The station’s five-storey headquarters in the southern suburbs of Beirut was bombed in the first hours of the war, injuring five staff. But the skeleton team working that night knew the evacuation drill and the location of a back-up studio, so al-Manar was off the air for only ten minutes.

For the next three nights the jets returned, pounding even the rubble with 500lb bombs after rumours that al-Manar was broadcasting from an underground bunker.

The station is now believed to be broadcasting from apartments in some of Beirut’s most fashionable streets, empty office blocks and basements, but the whereabouts of al-Manar’s newsreaders is shrouded in as much secrecy and protection as the hiding place of Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah’s leader.

Its technicians move their satellite dishes around more rapidly than Hezbollah fighters can shift their rocket launchers, and the question being asked in Israel is why its military, backed by its formidable intelligence services, cannot silence the voice of the Shia militia.

Ibrahim Farhat, al-Manar’s public relations director, said: “We knew this day was coming, so we took suitable precautions across all of Lebanon.”

Mr Farhat said he had no idea how many studios were still operating, and cannot or will not say how al-Manar manages to avoid giving away its satellite signal, but insists: “We consider it our duty to carry on, even if it costs us our lives.”

He said that several of the station’s installations had been hit, but that normal service always resumed within seconds.

Israel cannot destroy the international satellite al-Manar uses, as it is shared by Western broadcasters, so it must find the station’s own up-link satellite dish carried around on pick-up trucks, or target its clandestine studios and staff.

Mr Farhat said that al-Manar’s 350 employees had been told they did not need to come to work, but insisted that no one had stayed away. Staff keep in touch through pay-as-you-go mobile phones that cannot be traced, and a fleet of cars ferry them to that day’s studio.

The station’s message is crude and unrelenting: The “resistance” is winning, its enemies are hurting.

Aside from constant footage of its fighters charging through fields and loading their Katyusha rockets, there are images of dead Israeli soldiers and Hezbollah’s own “martyrs” slain on the battlefield, all accompanied by stirring martial music. Every few minutes images of Sheikh Nasrallah appear, being hugged by fighters, or stroking the face of one of his men being lowered into a coffin. Extracts of his speeches are repeated almost every hour. A weatherman stands in front of a map. He points to where Hezbollah missiles have landed, and zooms in on the latest damage done to Lebanon.

The station pirates Israeli TV pictures, supplying its own insulting commentary in Hebrew. Ehud Olmert, the Israeli Prime Minister, is depicted wearing a Nazi armband and a Hitler-style moustache. President Bush has blood dripping from his lips.

But it does not solely broadcast propaganda. Al-Manar was the first to report the kidnapping of the two Israeli soldiers on July 12, an hour after their abduction. It was the first to report that an Israeli naval ship had been hit by a Hezbollah missile, and that Israeli commandos had launched a raid on Baalbek this week. It regularly reports the deaths of Israeli soldiers before they are confirmed by Israel.

Sheikh Nasrallah’s latest broadcast on Thursday night was filmed by his own cameraman, and al-Manar was given an hour’s notice that the tape was on its way. When it appeared, householders turned up the volume so that people in the street could listen. West Beirut came to a virtual standstill during the 40-minute address.

But Mr Farhat denies that the station takes orders from Hezbollah. “If we do not believe a story that Hezbollah gives us, we won’t run it,” he said. Al-Manar first broadcast in 1990, has an annual budget of $15 million (£8 million) and claims an audience of 200 million across the Muslim world.

But its success has as much to do with its televising of Lebanon’s premier football league and Arab soap operas as for mobilising support for Hezbollah.

US companies such as Pepsi-Cola and Procter & Gamble used to advertise until al-Manar was blacklisted by the White House as the world’s only terrorist TV station. The most damage Israel has been able to inflict has been to interrupt its broadcasts by superimposing its own message on the screen.

The past three weeks have turned al-Manar’s broadcasters into local heroes. Fatma al-Birri, a newsreader, said: “When I’m on the air I feel like I am battling the enemy alongside Hezbollah fighters, though we sit on our armchairs while they fight battles.”


Al-Manar’s normal schedules were scrapped on July 12 to provide round-the-clock coverage of the war. A typical hour:

·  14.00: News bulletin opens with a Hezbollah song, a verse from the Koran and the slogan: “Lebanon we are your men to liberate the land of the south.” Newsreader recites casualty figures

·  14.05: Video montage of attacks on Israeli units before withdrawal in 2000

·  14.10: A Hezbollah MP is interviewed, followed by a 15-minute phone-in, with each caller praising Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah. A parade of Hezbollah units through Beirut, which includes boys carrying guns

·  14.25: Film of dead and wounded Israeli troops and grieving relatives, apparently pirated from Israeli TV. Slogans such as “Israelis, your leaders are dummies. They are tools in the hands of the US”

·  14.30: News bulletin with footage from bombing of Beirut, damaged bridges and a raid on a local port

·  14.32: Extract of pirated Israeli film of an IDF spokesman recounting day’s fighting

·  14.35: Propaganda film shows line-up of trucks carrying Katyusha rockets, and caricatures of Ehud Olmert and George Bush

·  14.40: Extracts from Sheikh Nasrallah’s speech

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on 6 August, 2006 by in Empire, War and Terror, Israel, Lebanon, Media, Strategy.

Timely Reminders

"Those who crusade, not for God in themselves, but against the devil in others, never succeed in making the world better, but leave it either as it was, or sometimes perceptibly worse than what it was, before the crusade began. By thinking primarily of evil we tend, however excellent our intentions, to create occasions for evil to manifest itself."
-- Aldous Huxley

"The only war that matters is the war against the imagination. All others are subsumed by it."
-- Diane DiPrima, "Rant", from Pieces of a Song.

"It is difficult
to get the news from poems
yet men die miserably every day
for lack
of what is found there"
-- William Carlos Williams, "Asphodel, That Greeny Flower"